Generating New Scouting Report
This page will refresh automatically when ready.
Scouting Report
Updated May 19, 2026
Jose Caballero placed on 10-day IL with broken right middle finger sustained while diving back into first base in Milwaukee on May 11, 2026. The 29-year-old shortstop had been performing well for the Yankees with a .259/.320/.400 line (105 wRC+) and 13 stolen bases over 41 games, earning the starting job over Anthony Volpe. Caballero claims he will return within the 10-day maximum. Anthony Volpe recalled from Triple-A to replace him. MRI results pending to determine exact return timeline.
Strengths
- + Strong offensive performance (.316 BA, .896 OPS over last 22 games)
- + Excellent baserunning with 13 stolen bases
- + Strong defensive metrics (+2 FRV fielding value per Statcast)
- + Earned starting shortstop role over top prospect Anthony Volpe
- + On pace for 4-win season
- + Confident about quick recovery (claims 10-day max)
- + Competitive mindset and gamesmanship
Weaknesses
- - Broken right middle finger injury
- - Underlying metrics not supporting offensive surge (exit velocity, hard-hit rate concerns)
- - Injury occurred in crucial game situation
- - Defensive sliding glove failed to protect finger
- - Return timeline uncertain pending MRI results
- - Vulnerable to being replaced by healthy Volpe
- - Injury risk from aggressive baserunning style
Injury Status: IL-10 -- Broken right middle finger sustained while diving back into first base in Milwaukee on May 11, 2026. Sliding glove protection failed. MRI and specialist evaluation scheduled. Exact return timeline unknown but player claims 10-day maximum.
About
Jose Montilla is a pitcher for the St Louis Cardinals.
Player Overview
P
St Louis Cardinals